CNBC European Business
CNBC European Business CNBC European Business
Subscribe Now!

Technology & Telecoms

October 2007

Wi-Fi Hotshot

Free Wi-Fi for every reader – if Martin Varsavsky has his way

Argentine-born entrepreneur Martin Varsavsky has created the world’s largest Wi-Fi network, and it’s free. But can “the perfect blend of socialism and capitalism” stand the test of time? By Barry Mansfield

The funky, lime-green offices of FON provide an air-conditioned respite from the fierce August sun of Alcobendas, on the northern outskirts of Madrid. Inside, a revolution is blazing with equal intensity. Martin Varsavsky, the company’s founder, is selling a utopia where consumers can share their home internet connection and, in return, surf the web for free via shared connections around the globe. Little wonder, then, that high-charging Wi-Fi hotspot providers such as T-Mobile and The Cloud are starting to feel the heat.

FON’s premise is that subscribers agree to share their existing internet connection via a router that the company provides. This means that someone in your street can be surfing the web via your router, which beams out its Wi-Fi hotspot over 100m. In return, those who sign up receive a user name and password allowing them to access other FON hotspots worldwide without having to pay a cent. Significantly, non-participants in the scheme can also access a FON hotspot at a cost of $3 (€2.20) per day, some $7 cheaper than the typical fee charged by established hotspot providers. A new router scheduled for release later this year promises a 400m range, meaning extortionate hotel internet charges could soon be a thing of the past as free Wi-Fi is beamed over from an office or café four streets away.

Varsavsky has earned a reputation for shaking up telecoms. The 47-year-old serial entrepreneur entered the sector in 1990, launching a call-back service called Viatel that he eventually sold for €1.2bn. He also founded Jazztel, the first alternative telecoms access provider on the Iberian Peninsula, which he sold for €1bn, and web portal Ya.com (including the second-largest Spanish-language online travel site), in which he invested €38m, later selling it for €550m to Deutsche Telekom’s T-Online International. Yet despite raking in around €300m from high-tech and telecoms ventures, and before that a biotechnology outfit, Medicorp Sciences, Varsavsky actually made his first million in New York City real estate at the forefront of the mid-1980s loft movement.

Born in Argentina, Varsavsky was 16 when his family of prominent Russian-Jewish intellectuals – his father was a Harvard-educated astrophysicist heading Argentina’s Radio Astronomical Institute – sought political asylum in the US following the murder of his cousin at the hands of Jorge Rafael Videla’s junta. He obtained degrees from NYU and Columbia and raised funds for his real estate venture while still at university.

Headquartered in Madrid since 1995, Varsavsky’s office at FON has the ultra-modern skyline of the Spanish capital’s high-tech quarter as its backdrop. Unsurprisingly it is kitted out with cutting-edge gadgetry, including the company’s signature router. His Apple laptop is plastered with logos of some of his recent investments, including the popular blog search tool Technorati. Varsavsky is a famously prolific blogger himself, with his views on the industry attracting over 200,000 fans monthly.

12345



Comments
AustinTX [7] Said,

I have been a Fonero since Fon launched 2 years ago, and I am one of the few remaining independant Fon bloggers. I am also the top poster in their English discussion board. I have to say that this article makes a fine Varsavsky biography, but there is much you may not realize has been glossed over. Your article is well-written, but despite being 5 pages, there is so much you did not say. Fon was originally proposed as a network of hotspots to provide connections for VOIP handsets, thus challenging the monopolistic telcos. They were also going to be a software wifi hotspot application running on PCs which had both Ethernet and wifi adapters installed. Fon changed plans for unknown reasons, and now denies that they had anything to do with phone calls. They like to pronounce their name as "Fawn" now, and claim that "FON" is a reference to the N. African Fon tribe! Fon is not free. There, i've said it, and I mean it. Fon does not "provide" a router, they sell it. True, it can be bought at a discount if you are invited, and discontinued models were given away in the past, but router sales may actually be how Fon makes most of their money now. What is free, for Fon, is the bandwidth provided by the Foneros who host Fon's hotspots. "Bill" Foneros are given no guarantee of profit, nor that they will find Fon hotspots wherever they travel. If they find one, they may use it for free, but there is a very poor chance of that in most of the world. This benefeit of Fon is enjoyed so rarely, that it is fundamentally wrong to emphasize it as Fon's purpose! Most of Fon's hotspots are not operating in locations that are accessible to the public. Foneros must provide the Internet connections, perform the installations, and basically stand quitetly aside, as Fon promises Despite Martin's quote, "Aliens" must register with Fon, and are counted as "Foneros" in company statistics. Compare the statistics between 1) Fon hotspots which remain up and running today, 2) Total of all Fon routers ever registered (Foneros can register as many hotspots as they like), and 3) total number of "Foneros" stated by Fon. Logically, there should be somewhat fewer Foneros than routers ever registered, but Fon claims a number far higher. Ergo, they *MUST* be throwing in "Aliens" without making that clear. Foneros must go through a manual, 2-week process to "unsubscribe", so that number simply appears to grow, even though many people have abandoned the Movement. Anyone can sign up to be an "Alien" in seconds, by providing an unverified email address, and then enjoy 15 minutes of free wifi, after watching a short advertisement. When time is up, just provide another string of letters that looks like an email address. These unverified accounts also migrate into "Foneros" later on, in Fon's statistics. *wink* Also, visits to Google and a long list of Fon's "partners" may be visited without even logging in. Under very routine circumstances, a Fonero must provide wifi for free to Aliens who have paid Fon for access, without getting any payment for it. Fon shares part of the profit* (NOT revenue) only with the Bill who hosted the hotspot which the Alien was at when s/he paid for a day of wifi. When the Alien roams to other Fon hotspots that day, none of the additional Bills are compensated. *Fon does not split the revenue. Fon splits the PROFIT, after "fees and taxes". "Fees and taxes" vary from country to country, and Fon will not itemize them to the Bills. Fon's customer service has bluntly told me that they will not answer that question, nor reveal who those "fees and taxes" are paid to. "Fees and taxes" take up more-or-less 33% of the $/€3 paid by the Alien, even when there ARE NO TAXES in a given country, like the USA. That money just dissapears somewhere! Fon then "splits" the remaining 66%, but holds it in their own bank accounts still longer; the Bill must wait until his balance has passed $20 before s/he may withdraw it through PayPal. Varsavsky's "serial entrepreneurship" tecnique has also been described as "pumping and dumping". Many Foneros fear that the statistical and definition games which Fon has been seen playing, means that Fon's value is being inflated so that it can be sold at profit. Varsavsky says Fon will become profitable at the end of 2009, but this doesn't mean that it's bills have been paid, nor it's investors seen a dime of profit. It really only marks the point where Fon stops operating at a loss. Fon's $5 router sales were brief periods when Fon wanted to clear it's shelves. Fon sold the Linksys for $25 plus tax and shipping, and now sells it's proprietary La Fonera, which is a rebranded Accton router, for $29.95 plus tax and shipping. This router only has a WAN port, so it's not possible to expand an existing LAN. If you want a single LAN port to attach your PC or switch to, there's the La Fonera Plus for $50-odd dollars, plus shipping. Fon's decision to abandon Linksys and Buffalo routers came after claiming that they were working on a dual-SSID *firmware*. Then they proudly touted the "router we had been asking for", which is a cheap POS that they can sell at profit and lock down the firmware so that we can't use it for other purposes if we find Fon to be unsatisfying. Foneros can still contribute their own compatible, discontinued model Linksys and Buffalo routers, but many people report that they are no longer able to register them, and thus benefeit from them - even though it still works fine as a Fon hotspot which you can pay to use! Fon's proprietary router remains trivial to hack, and the dual SSID is not a security feature; just a convienience. Fon's public SSID is completely unencrypted, so packet sniffers have no barriers to catching passwords, identities, and logging people's activities. Fon is not interested in our suggestion of offering VPN service, nor WPA-by-RADIUS logins. I think Fon could be a wonderful foundation for hotspot-in-a-box kits for people who want to set up community wifi, and small for-pay wifi networks. However, Fon's feature-set is very poor as compared with many other such "in-a-box" providers. Fon did not innovate this hotspot concept; they simply rebranded an open-source router firmware, and stripped out a few inconvienient features. Fon's Achilles Heel is the dishonesty by which they operate, and the discouraging way in which they take their Fonero members for granted, even suppressing them. Fon is no longer a cutting edge leader, but the progress, and mistakes which they made, may serve a future Movement in suceeding where Fon failed.
Posted: 8/26/2008 10:48:54 PM
 

Submit a comment


Email Address:
 
Display Name:
 
Comment:
 
Enter the code shown:

 

 
MOST POPULAR ARTICLES

Pyramid Property

A look at the exciting enigma of the Egyptian real estate market

Wi-Fi Hotshot

Free Wi-Fi for every reader – if Martin Varsavsky has his way

Empire Of The Senses

Banyan Tree has moved beyond the standard spa business model

Delivering The Next Windfall

Improved transport links are creating new property hotspots across the continent

The Jewel Of Africa

New land laws in the tranquil paradise of Ghana will make life a lot easier for inward investors
 
RELATED ARTICLES